Comment

Enclosure I Atlantic Fleet Weapons Training Facility/Vieques P.R. Responses to Public Comments on Documents developed under the January 2000 RCRA Administrative Order, during Public Review Period August 7, 2002 through November 8, 2002. June 23, 2003. Comment Source / Comment Location (paragraph in letter) Date

1)Center ForIntroduction Public EnvironmentalFinal Work Plan for Community Relations Plan Oversight (CPEO)letter,Final Description of Current Conditions November 7, 2002 Final Work Plan for Groundwater Baseline Investigation Draft Final Work Plan and Sampling and Analysis Plan Soil and Groundwater Background Investigation Master and Site Specific Sampling Plan

CPEO - Final WorkIntroduction Plan for1.3 RCRA Facility Investigation ommunit RCelations Pylan2.2 - Community Relations Work Plan Comments,2.3.2 - Community Interviews 11/20022.3 3 - Completing the CRP . 2.4 - Public Participation Implementation

2.4.3 - Public Comment on Proposed Corrective Measure Page 1

paragraph 3 paragraph 4 & 5 paragraph 2 paragraph 3 paragraph 1 2, & 3 paragraph 4 paragraph 5 paragraph 1 & 2 paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 3 paragraph 2 paragraph 3 paragraph 4 paragraph 5 paragraphs 1 & 2

paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraphs 3-6 paragraph 7 paragraph 1 paragraph 2

Applicable Responses in Enclosures II, III and IV A, B, C A, B, C, L L L A, B, C, E, F, G H, I, J, L E, F, G H, I, J K K K A, I, J A, H A, C, D A, H, L L A, B, C, H, T L L L L L N-28 L L, N L L

Enclosure I Atlantic Fleet Weapons Training Facility/Vieques P.R. Responses to Public Comments on Documents developed under the January 2000 RCRA Administrative Order, during Public Review Period August 7, 2002 through November 8, 2002. June 23, 2003. Comment Source / Comment Location (paragraph in letter) Date CPEO - Final1.3 - Site and Environmental Setting Characteristics Description of Current Conditions Report, 11/20021.3.2 - Land Use 1.3.5 - Soils 1.3.6 - Hydrology 1.3.7 - Hydrogeology

1.4.1 - RCRA Facility Assessments 1.4.2 - Groundwater Resources / Well Inventory Investigation

1.4.3 - Hydrogeological Investigation 1.4.4 - Aerial Photographic Analysis 1.4.5 - Personal Interviews and Navy Records Search

Page 2

paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 1 paragraph 2

paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 3 paragraph 4 paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 3 paragraph 4 paragraph 5 paragraph 6 paragraph 7 paragraph 1-2 paragraph 3 paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 3 paragraph 4 paragraph 5 paragraph 6 paragraph 7 paragraph 8

Applicable Responses in Enclosures II, III and IV A, C, E, F, G E, F, G E, F, G G, M M M M M M M E, F, G B M M N M N M M J G, H, I, J N-10 N-10 C B, C A, B, C A, C B, D M M M

Enclosure I Atlantic Fleet Weapons Training Facility/Vieques P.R. Responses to Public Comments on Documents developed under the January 2000 RCRA Administrative Order, during Public Review Period August 7, 2002 through November 8, 2002. June 23, 2003. Comment Source / Comment Location (paragraph in letter) Date paragraph 9 paragraph 10 paragraph 11 paragraph 12 paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 3 paragraph 4 paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 3 paragraph 4 paragraph 5

Section 2 CPEO - Final2.1 - SWMU 01 Description of Current Conditions Report, 11/2002 (continued) 2.2 - SWMU 02 2.3 - SWMU 04

2.4 SWMU 05 -2.5 - SWMU 06 2.6 - SWMU 07 2.7 - SWMU 08 2.8 - SWMU 10 2.9 - SWMU 12 2.10 - AOC A 2.11 - AOC F 2.12 - AOC G 2.13 - Photo-Identified Areas

Page 3

paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 1

Applicable Responses in Enclosures II, III and IV E M A A A, B A, H M M, N-23 A A, B, C, N-23 M D M M M M M M M M M M M M M M A M, O, P B, N-12

Enclosure I

Atlantic Fleet Weapons Training Facility/Vieques P.R.

Responses to Public Comments on Documents developed under the January 2000 RCRA Administrative Order, during Public Review Period August 7, 2002 through November 8, 2002.

June 23, 2003. Comment Source / Date

Comment Location (paragraph in letter)

3.2 - Exposure Pathways

Page 4

paragraph 2 paragraph 3

Applicable Responses in Enclosures II, III and IV A, L, T A, L, T O, T

Enclosure I Atlantic Fleet Weapons Training Facility/Vieques P.R. Responses to Public Comments on Documents developed under the January 2000 RCRA Administrative Order, during Public Review Period August 7, 2002 through November 8, 2002. June 23, 2003. Comment Source / Comment Location (paragraph in letter) Date

CPEO - Draft Final1.1 - Purpose and Objectives Work Plan and Sampling Analysis Plan, Soil and Groundwater Background Investigation, 11/2002

2.1 Hydrogeology and Soils -

2.2 - Aerial Photography Survey 2.3 - Sample Locations

2.3.1 - Groundwater Sampling Locations and Analysis

2.3.2 - Soil Sampling Locations

3.2 - Incorporating Background Analytical Results into Remedial Investigations and Feasibility Studies

Page 5

paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 3 paragraph 5 paragraph 6 paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 3 paragraph 1& 2 paragraph 3 paragraph 4 paragraph 6 paragraph 7 paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 3 paragraph 4 paragraph 5 paragraph 6 paragraph 7 paragraph 8 paragraph 9 paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 3 paragraph 2 paragraph 3 paragraph 4 paragraph 5 & 6

Applicable Responses in Enclosures II, III and IV A, K K K K K I, J, K, T I, J, K, T O, T N-10, N-12 K K K K K K I, K K K K I, J, T M M T K, M K K K K K K

Enclosure I Atlantic Fleet Weapons Training Facility/Vieques P.R. Responses to Public Comments on Documents developed under the January 2000 RCRA Administrative Order, during Public Review Period August 7, 2002 through November 8, 2002. June 23, 2003. Comment Source / Comment Location (paragraph in letter) Date 4.1.2 - Field Sampling Analysis 4.2.2 - Data Validations 4.4 - Investigation Reports [including municipality on Draft report distribution] CPEO - Final WorkIntroduction GPlraon fodrater1.1.2 - Previous Investigations un w Baseline1.1.3 - Regional Hydrogeology Investigation, 11/20021.1.4 - Site Hydrogeology 1.2 - Project Objectives

2.1 - Project Planning 2.2 - Groundwater Sampling

Section 3 Section 4 Appendix A Appendix B Appendix C

CPEO - FinalIntroduction [paragraphs 1-3] SMpaesctiefri ca nWdo rSkit ePl1.1 - RFI Background an Phase I RFI,1.3.2 - Land Use 11/20021.3.7 - Groundwater

Page 6

paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 1 paragraph 1 & 2 paragraph 3 paragraph 4 paragraph 1 paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 3 paragraphs 1-2 paragraphs 1-2

paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 3 paragraph 4 paragraph 5

Applicable Responses in Enclosures II, III and IV K, Q K, Q, V L, K H, I, J, T I, J, M O O T H, I, J, T H, I, J, K, T I, J, K, O, T L H, I, J, T Q Q L L T T O O O O O A, H, I, J O E T

Enclosure I Atlantic Fleet Weapons Training Facility/Vieques P.R. Responses to Public Comments on Documents developed under the January 2000 RCRA Administrative Order, during Public Review Period August 7, 2002 through November 8, 2002. June 23, 2003. Comment Source / Comment Location (paragraph in letter) Date

1.4 - Identification of Potential Receptors

1.5.1 - Solid Waste Management Units and Areas of Concern 1.5.2 - Documentation of Release CPEO - Final2.1.1 - Historical Aerial Photograph Analysis Master and Site2.1.3 - SWMU 1 - Camp Garcia Landfill Specific Work Plan Phase I, 11/2002 (continued)

2.1.4 - Fuels Off-Loading Site

Page 7

paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 3 paragraph 4 paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 1 paragraph 2 surface soil, paragraph 1 subsurface groundwater, paragraph 1 & 2 groundwater, paragraph 3 groundwater, paragraph 4 groundwater, paragraph 5 geophysics, paragraph 1 geophysics, paragraph 2 investigation planning sampling location info adequacy of subsurface sampling pipeline sampling shoreline and marine sampling marine investigation

Applicable Responses in Enclosures II, III and IV O T O, T M, O, T C F, G A, B, C M M H, N-24 S H, N-25 A, H, N-25 A, H, N-25 Q A, N-23 A, N-23 A A A, H A A A, M

2.1.5 - SWMU 4 - Waste Areas of Building 303

Enclosure I Atlantic Fleet Weapons Training Facility/Vieques P.R. Responses to Public Comments on Documents developed under the January 2000 RCRA Administrative Order, during Public Review Period August 7, 2002 through November 8, 2002. June 23, 2003. Comment Source / Comment Location (paragraph in letter)Applicable Responses Date in Enclosures II, III and IV Q A, H M M M M A A, C M, P M, E M, P A, K K M, P M N-26 M A H, I A, P M, P M M

CPEO - Final2.1.6 - SWMU 5 - Spent Battery Accumulation Area Master and Site S Work Plan Phpaescief iI,c 11/20022.1.7 - SWMU 6 - Waste Oil and Paint Accumulation (continued)Area 2.1.8 - SWMU 7 - Waste Oil Accumulation Area

2.1.9 - SWMU 8

2.1.10 - SWMU 10

2.1.11 - SWMU 12 2.1.12 - AOC A

Page 8

sampling procedure for VOCs groundwater sampling previous sampling building 303, paragraph 1 building 303, paragraph 3 adjacent activity soil sampling Other adjacent sites background onsite use activities associated with waste disposal activity regulations soil sampling background, paragraph 1 background, paragraph 2 site use, paragraph 1 site use, paragraph 2 document consistency existing data soil sampling groundwater treatment plant infrastructure site use site characterization site use

Enclosure I Atlantic Fleet Weapons Training Facility/Vieques P.R. Responses to Public Comments on Documents developed under the January 2000 RCRA Administrative Order, during Public Review Period August 7, 2002 through November 8, 2002. June 23, 2003. Comment Source / Comment Location (paragraph in letter) Date

2.1.13 - AOC F

2.1.14 - AOC G 2.1.15 - Future Steps in the RCRA Process 2.4 - Task RF 2.6 - Task PP CPEO - Final8.0 - Analytical Procedures Master and Site S ci Work Plan Phpaesef iI,c 11/2002Attachment A (continued)Photo-identified Areas

Potential Areas of Concern

Chemical Warfare Material Depleted Uranium 2A) PREQB,Specific Comments Carmelo Vazquez Fernandez, letter, 11/6/2002

Page 9

additional sampling existing data site statistics soil sampling soil sampling paragraph 3

paragraph 1 paragraph 2 & 3 paragraph 1 paragraph 3 paragraph 4 paragraph 5 paragraph 6 paragraph 7 paragraph 8 & 9 paragraph 1 paragraph 2 paragraph 3 paragraph 4 paragraph 5 paragraph 6 paragraph 1 paragraph 2 I.1.a.1 I.1.a.2 I.1.b.1 I.1.c.1 I.1.d.1 I.1.e.1

Applicable Responses in Enclosures II, III and IV A, H, M M A, M A M A, F N L T, V T, V *** M, N-10 & 12 M, N-10 & 12 M, N-10 & 12 M, N-10 & 12 B, N-10 & 12 N-10 & 12 A, N-10 & 12 A, B A, B A, B A A, H A, H M A, E, G, N-11 M T A, S, T M, P M, U N-27 N-28

Enclosure I Atlantic Fleet Weapons Training Facility/Vieques P.R. Responses to Public Comments on Documents developed under the January 2000 RCRA Administrative Order, during Public Review Period August 7, 2002 through November 8, 2002. June 23, 2003. Comment Source / Date

2A) PREQB, Carmelo Vazquez Fernandez, letter, 11/6/2002 (continued)

[re EQB point of contact] [re location of files at EQB]

Comment Location (paragraph in letter) I.2.a.1 I.2.b.1 I.2.b.2 I.2.c.1 I.3.a I.3.b I.3.c I.4.a.1 I.4.b.1 I.5.a I.5.b II.1.a II.1.b II.2.a II.2.b II.2.c II.3 III.1.a III.1.b III.2.a III.2.b III.2.c III.3.a III.3.b III.4.a III.5.a III.6.a III.7.a III.8.a III.9.a.1 III.9.a.2 III.10

Page 10

Applicable Responses in Enclosures II, III and IV V A A A N-28 V V N-29 N-29 N-11 N-30 K K K K K K A N-23 A A A A E, M A A A, H, N-31 A A, H A M K

Enclosure I Atlantic Fleet Weapons Training Facility/Vieques P.R. Responses to Public Comments on Documents developed under the January 2000 RCRA Administrative Order, during Public Review Period August 7, 2002 through November 8, 2002. June 23, 2003. Comment Source / Date

Comment Location (paragraph in letter)

General Comments

Page 11

III.11 III.12 III.13 III.14 III.15 III.16 III.17 III.18 IV.1 IV.2 IV.3 1.a 1.b 2.a 2.b 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

Applicable Responses in Enclosures II, III and IV N-1 & N-2 V N-32 N-33 M, A, H, T A, H, N-25 A, H N-34 N-35 T A V A, V V V N-11 A, H N-36 N-9 N-35 T